birddog

Cream City Real Estate Plans 92-Unit Wauwatosa Multifamily Project on Mayfair Road

Cream City Real Estate Investments plans a 92-unit multifamily development on North Mayfair Road in Wauwatosa, supported by a new $2.85 million TIF district.

By Colin Percy · May 22, 2026

The Wauwatosa Common Council has approved the creation of Tax Incremental District (TID) 17 to facilitate a new 92-unit market-rate apartment development on North Mayfair Road. Developed by Cream City Real Estate Investments, the project will transform a 1.7-acre site currently occupied by two office buildings. The development will feature a mix of studio, one, two, and three-bedroom apartments alongside 110 parking stalls, including 51 structured spaces. Resident amenities are set to include a fitness center, club room, and outdoor courtyard.

The city plans to provide approximately $2.85 million in development incentives on a pay-as-you-go basis, as part of a total $5 million project cost investment. The project is anticipated to generate $19.6 million in new taxable value by the end of 2027. Construction is scheduled to commence in June 2026, with completion expected by July 2027.

Companies mentioned

developer

Cream City Real Estate Investments

More news from Wisconsin

Get personalized project alerts in your inbox

Daily emails covering the projects and news that match your service area, building types, and the project stages you bid on.

Free now — first 50 founding members lock in 30% off at launch.

Free. One click to unsubscribe. No tracking pixels.